From: flaviaR on

On 27-Dec-2006, Banty <Banty_member(a)newsguy.com> wrote:

> I guess those New Orleans Catholics should kindly keep their "Mardi Gras"
> festival quietly in their homes. For shame - using public streets.

The odd thing is that the strict Catholics doubtless do...

Susan
From: flaviaR on

On 23-Dec-2006, "Sancho Panza" <otterpower(a)xhotmail.com> wrote:

> > A creche and a menorah are religious symbols. An Xmas tree is not.
>
> One person's opinon. Nothing more.

Certainly not the government's opinion - as if they should have one at all!
But that's another story....

Susan
From: James A. Donald on
"Sancho Panza"
> > > A creche and a menorah are religious symbols. An
> > > Xmas tree is not.

> > One person's opinon. Nothing more.

flaviaR(a)verizon.net
> Certainly not the government's opinion

The court's opinion, expressed in case after case, cases
I have repeatedly cited, is that a creche and a menorah
are religious symbols and a Xmas tree is not.

--
----------------------
We have the right to defend ourselves and our property, because
of the kind of animals that we are. True law derives from this
right, not from the arbitrary power of the omnipotent state.

http://www.jim.com/ James A. Donald
From: Al Klein on
On 29 Dec 2006 15:09:48 -0800, usenet_trash(a)yahoo.de wrote:

>
>Al Klein wrote:
>> usenet_trash(a)yahoo.de wrote:
>> >> >> >The central govt should
>> >> >> >transfer all power to the smaller entities and act solely as
>> >> >> >representative for foreign representatives.
>> >> >> That'll never happen in the US. But, if it did, we'd have civil war
>> >> >> with a lot more than 2 sides.
>> >> >Why is this believe so widespread?
>> >> Because some of us know about evolution and about how human nature
>> >> evolved. Altruism outside the group is usually exhibited by extinct species.
>> >I fail to see why this should have anything to do with the issue of
>> >selfgovernment.
>> Usenet's not the place to get 10 years of education in 5 minutes. When
>> you understand how anthropoids work you may have a bit more
>> understanding of the problem.
>
>Forget your pseudo-realism. Apparently you confuse 'how humans work'
>with 'how humans work who claim to be the government'.

I refuse to engage in a battle of wits with an unarmed man.

<plonk>
From: nfolkert on
flaviaR(a)verizon.net wrote:
> On 26-Dec-2006, nfolkert(a)gmail.com wrote:
>
> > > Yeah, I'm sure you've got a Jewish friend or two. Yes, there may be a
> > > scattering of Jews around who might. The overwhelming majority don't.
> >
> > According to a survey of Jewish families of interfaith couples -- which
> > account for one-third of Jewish families total and over half of Jewish
> > families formed in the last decade -- about 90% will celebrate
> > Christmas, though the overwhelming majority of these will be secular
> > celebrations. (http://pnnonline.org/article.php?sid=7123)
> >
> Which means that not only do a majorityof Jews NOT celebrate Xmas
> (even your numbers show this),

I never said a majority of Jews celebrated Christmas. I was responding
to someone who asserted in this thread that virtually no Jews
celebrated secular traditions that are associated with Christmas, such
as decorating trees. I thought examining some relevant surveys might
shed more light on approximately how widespread such behavior is. Half
of interfaith Jewish families and one fifth of entirely Jewish families
(if these survey numbers are to be trusted) is not "a scattering", even
if it is not a majority.

> it is, as we all thought, only those who
> do not really identify with being Jewish.

This was a survey of families that do identify as Jewish, and are
raising their children as Jewish, but where one partner was not
originally Jewish. I would suspect that non-religious interfaith
families have a significantly higher participation rate still. But I
doubt I could find a survey demonstrating this.

[...]

- Nate